Most new markets get planned as a smaller copy of the home market: same channels, same offer, same budget logic. Then two quarters in, the market isn't hitting plan, and the board wants to know whether to double down or pull back. Nobody can answer, because the plan never said where the demand was supposed to come from.
There's a better order of operations. Score the market first, down to the ZIP code, then decide where to spend.
Separate the four questions
When a market underperforms, four different questions usually get blended into one:
- Is there demand where we're looking?
- Are we reaching it?
- Are we converting it?
- Are we keeping the appointments we set?
Each has its own evidence and points to a different fix. Demand scoring answers the first one before you spend, so that when the numbers come in, you know which of the other three to look at.
What goes into a demand score
For a roofing or exteriors company, demand comes from two places: homes that are due for work, and homes that weather has damaged. Both can be measured before you enter a market.
Housing
Public Census housing data tells you, ZIP by ZIP, how many owner-occupied homes there are, how old the housing stock is, and what homes are worth. An older, owner-occupied neighborhood with solid home values is a different market from a new subdivision of rentals, even inside the same city.
Storm history
Regional storm records go back years. The model I built used eleven years of storm history for every residential ZIP in the company's markets. One season can mislead; a decade shows where hail and wind keep coming back. A ZIP that took three hail events in a few years and none since is a different bet from one that gets hit every other spring.
Two lenses, not one
Retail and storm demand behave differently, so they get scored separately. A ZIP can be strong for retail replacement and weak for storm work, or the other way around. Blending them hides both.
Weighing a new market, or a market that isn't hitting plan? Walk me through it in a working conversation.
Book a working conversation →Thirty minutes, and confidential.
Four outputs, each for a different person
A score only helps if it reaches the people making decisions, in a form they'll use. The version I built produced four things:
- A territory view for sales, so managers can see where the demand sits and route reps accordingly.
- A clean target list for outside lead vendors, the ZIPs you want leads from, with none of your internal scoring exposed.
- A summary for leadership, short enough to take into a board meeting.
- An exclusion list: the ZIPs to keep out of the service area entirely.
Why the exclusion list saves the most money
Every market has places that look busy and never pay back. Long drives, low-value housing stock, areas saturated by other contractors after every storm. Leads come in, the calendar fills, crews and reps spend days there, and the signed contracts don't cover the cost.
Saying no to those ZIPs in advance is the single cheapest decision in market entry. It protects the budget, the reps' time and the first impression the brand makes in a new city.
What a score can't tell you
A demand score says where the work should be. It doesn't say whether you can win it. Three things sit outside the model and need a local read:
- The competition. Who already owns the market's search results, referral networks and storm response, and how long they've been there.
- Your team. Whether you can recruit reps and crews in that market at the pace the demand calls for.
- Your brand. A name that means something at home means nothing in a new city on day one, so the first months cost more per sale than the home market does.
Put those next to the score before the budget moves. A high-demand ZIP with a dominant local competitor and no crew coverage may still be a place to wait.
Once you're in the market
Scoring gets you in the right places. After that, the same discipline that runs a home market runs a new one: every lead source on one read, signed contract value traced back to the source, and a monthly look at which ZIPs are paying back against their score. Where the two disagree, you've learned something about the market or about your marketing, and either one is worth knowing early.
If you're already in a market that isn't hitting plan, the same score works in reverse. It separates a demand problem from a reach, conversion or appointment problem, so the fix goes where the problem actually is.
A new market isn't a smaller copy of your home market. Scored first, it doesn't have to be a guess either.